Property Management of Hayward: Lost Dutchman Lodge

A Hayward, Wisconsin vacation rental

Property/area video(s)

Insure your trip with Nationwide Travel Insurance.

Send an email inquiry.
  • Share this WI cabin rental

  • Bedrooms - 4
  • Bathrooms - 4
  • Sleeps - 14
  • Pets Considered
  • On Teal Lake
  • WEEKLY ONLY June through August. Off-season nightly.

Lost Dutchman Lodge is a three-level, wood-and-glass cabin with a finished basement and a loft. On the main level, a large, fully equipped kitchen and breakfast bar with stools shares an open floor plan with a formal dining area with seating for six and a cozy living space with a sectional and a stone fireplace. One full side of this vacation home is constructed with floor-to-ceiling windows, providing a panoramic view of Teal lake and Pine Island and filtering healthy, natural light into the shared spaces.

On the lower level, guests will find additional lounge and recreation space with a second large sectional, a futon and a flat-screen TV. The lower level also has a separate, spacious guest laundry room with open counters for folding. Lost Dutchman Lodge is equipped with four private bedrooms and can easily accommodate up to 16 overnight guests. Four full baths — including a master bath with a Jacuzzi tub — ensure that the whole group can be ready in good time for the day’s adventures. This upscale cabin is set on 13 private acres.

Sleeping Arrangements: Lost Dutchman’s four private bedrooms are furnished with four queen-sized beds, two sets of bunkbeds with twin-sized beds lofted over full-sized beds and a full-sized futon.
NOTE: Towels are not provided at this property.


  • Pets Allowed
  • Air Conditioning
  • Linens Provided
  • Washer and Dryer
  • Furnished Kitchen
  • Vehicle and Trailer Parking
  • Fireplace
  • Outdoor Firepit
  • Outdoor Grill
  • ATV/Snowmobile Trail
  • Pier/Dock
  • Deck or Patio
  • OK to Bring Firewood
  • WiFi Internet
  • Satellite/Cable TV
  • Year-round Rental
  • Canoe/Kayak

Unique Features

The property at Lost Dutchman Lodge abuts the 1,024-acre Teal Lake with a shrubby shoreline overpassed by a private dock. The dock extends out over the calm waters of a small, sheltered bay area, and guests are provided with a two-person bench at the end to enjoy the view and the lake breeze.

With a maximum depth of 31 feet, Teal Lake is a popular fishing destination. Guests can expect to find game fish such as large and smallmouth bass, northern pike, pan fish, musky and walleye in its waters. The land surrounding the lake and the cabin is relatively level and lightly wooded with mature birch and pine. Guests are encouraged to explore the area on bikes or on foot.

Things To Do

This secluded vacation property is surrounded by national forest land, with hundreds of miles of scenic driving routes and an elaborate nature trail system that is in use year-round by tourists who flock to the beautiful Northwoods region to enjoy hiking and biking, cross-country skiing, snowmobiles and ATVs. The CAMBA trails are home to renowned outdoor competitions and events, such at the Chequamegon Fat Tire Festival, the Mt. Borah Epic and the Fat Bike Birkie. The trails are kept well-groomed in all seasons, and rentals can be found nearby for every variety of outdoor adventure equipment.

Local restaurants and taverns can be found near the trail inlets for visitors to break from their explorations and experience the local flavor. There is also a selection of dining venues set right on the lake shores, many of which feature live music from local artists. Public beaches can be found on several of the area lakes, and the Namekagon and St. Croix Rivers are great for canoeing, kayaking and tubing. Lost Dutchman Lodge is located only 20 minutes from downtown Hayward, where visitors will find other tourist attractions such as the Sawyer County Fair, The Sawyer County Historical Society museum or the Lumberjack World Championships.



April 2021

45678 9 10

May 2021

910111213 14 15
23 24 25 26 27 28 29

June 2021

6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30  

July 2021

    1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

August 2021

1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28

September 2021

56 7 8 9 10 11
12 131415161718

October 2021


November 2021


December 2021


January 2022


February 2022

2021222324 25 26

March 2022


* Please contact owner to ensure availability.

Rates & Specials

$450 - $450 night

$2500 - $3000 week

The average rental rage for Lost Dutchman Lodge ranges from $2,500 for $3,000 per week.

During the peak season (between Memorial Day and Labor Day) the rental rate is $3,000 per week. During the off season, the rental rate is $2,500 per week. Please contact the manager for daily rates during the off season.

We require a deposit of 1/2 the rent + $79.13 booking fee. The balance + sales tax is due 21 days prior to your arrival. If you reserve within 4 weeks of arrival, we do require payment in full at time of reservation. A security deposit is a hold on your credit card during your stay - If no damage occurs during your stay, we release the hold. Check-in is 4:00 pm and check-out is 9:00 am.

No additional charge for children 3 years of age or younger. Additional $25/per night or $175/per week + sales tax for additional guests.

Contact Information

8728 W Elephant Rock Rd
Hayward, WI 54843
See this location on Google Maps

Please mention

Visit property website and social pages (if listed) return and send an inquiry. No booking website traveler fees here - YOU RENT DIRECT.


About the Owner/Manager

Property Management of Hayward is fully licensed and insured. We can find the perfect 4-season vacation home rental (small cabins to luxury retreats) for your family or group thanks to our large selection of Northern Wisconsin cabins and lake homes in Hayward and Cable. We are in our 25th year of providing quality vacation home rentals and are proud members of the Sawyer County Snowmobile and ATV Alliance, Hayward Chamber of Commerce, American Birkebeiner Foundation and Chequamegon Area Mountain Bike Association.

Safely book direct at the guaranteed lowest rate. Insure your trip with Nationwide Travel Insurance.

Owner or manager will be contacting you.